“There is an island in the North Atlantic…” So begins the introduction to “The Curse of Oak Island”, a reality television show soon to enter it’s twelfth season. Ostensibly it is a reality show about two brothers looking for a treasure on an island in Nova Scotia’s largest bay.
It has all the hallmarks of a thoroughly disreputable reality television series. It is brought to us by the producers of “Ancient Aliens”, Prometheus Entertainment. It shares the same cheesy narration and writing style. It seems primed to be the punchline of many jokes.
I watched it for almost five seasons, assuming it was a show about two brothers, wasting their time and money looking for a treasure that didn’t exist. Every season it performed it’s little line dance, featuring a cornucopia of conspiracy theories and pseudo-academic rubbish.
Every episode the questions were some version of, “What will they find? Gold, jewels? Priceless relics?” And the answer was, “Of course not you barmy bottlenosed lemming!” “They’re going to find *NOTHING*, *NADA*, *BUPKIS*!” But I kept watching. It might have been the domain of the lunatic fringe, but it was entertaining.
The relationship between the brothers made it interesting. The somewhat sick attraction of what appeared to be a slow motion train wreck made it difficult to stop watching. When will they run out of money and/or motivation? When will the show get cancelled?
Then, season five, episode ten, but who’s counting? Something completely unexpected happened—something that quite literally turned my worldview upside down. Something that shattered my personal smugness and conceit. Something that made me aware, especially as I processed what I had seen, that most of the history I had been taught, was rubbish, and so many theories I assumed were for the ignorant and gullible, were quite possibly true.
Gary Drayton, a metal detection expert, with the help of Rick Lagina, found a little lead cross on the Smith’s Cove beach on Oak Island. A lead cross that would fit into the palm of your hand, that could only have been of medieval European origins.
In episodes that followed it was proven, quite conclusively, that this cross was from a mine in Southern France, that was only worked during the early Medieval period, in an area dominated by the Knights Templar. The cross exactly matched a carving of a cross from a prison in Dome France, where it was carved by Knights Templar where they were held after King Philip of France and Pope Clement V attempted to destroy their order.
And it wasn’t a one off, accidentally dropped their by someone else, at a later date. Other pieces of lead, decorative and otherwise, have been found at other locations on the island, that also originated from that same mine in southern France.